When Hewitt calls something 'arbitrary' he means that for a person to learn this something they must be explicitly told. On the other hand, when Hewitt calls something 'necessary' he means that it is quite the opposite. Things that are necessary are called so because they must be that way, so typically these truths can be figured out (with some work) by oneself.
For any given lesson there may be both topics that are arbitrary and topics that are necessary. I think that a great way to figure out which are which is to try to teach yourself the lesson and carefully comb through it. By putting yourself in the shoes of a student and pretending to know only what they know can you figure out this idea? If yes, then the topic is necessary. If no, the topic is arbitrary and should be explained explicitly.
I really like this idea of necessary vs. arbitrary. Whenever I am teaching or tutoring students I always let them know when a convention arises so that they don't feel like they're "not getting it". I think that if we can create lessons that allow students to do the work and discover for themselves the necessary information then we will have done a beautiful thing. Planning lessons in this way is definitely more difficult, but the reward on the students' side is worth it. We always want the students to be 'doing the math' as much as possible.
Great summary and comments, Fraser! We will be experimenting with lesson planning around 'arbitrary' and 'necessary' in class tomorrow.
ReplyDelete