I believe that most high school students would be convinced by either deductive proofs or dynamic proofs, but that the effectiveness of each would vary student to student. In a more advanced class or for more senior grades I think that the students may possess enough mathematical scepticism to desire a rigorous deductive proof, but younger students or more casual mathematicians would be satisfied by the dynamic proofs that are possible using software.
I believe that the the deductive proofs are more mathematically rigorous and should always be accessible by the teacher if students are not satisfied by the dynamic proofs, because I feel that no aspect of mathematics should be taken on faith. Each student may possess a different standard on how much evidence or proof they need before they'll accept something as true - many will be happy to prove to themselves with simply a dynamic demonstration of proof, but there will always be more sceptical students that want to see real rigor.
There are certain tools like Euclid: The Game that are very valuable because they combine dynamic and rigorous proofs and let students see the foundations of geometry while developing trust in the software, all while saving the frustration of students having to draw compass and straightedge constructions and making errors. During my university geometry courses we were suggested to play the game to help build a foundation in the Elements as it would help with our constructions on exams.
Friday, 9 December 2016
Monday, 5 December 2016
SNAP Reflection
The SNAP Math Fair was a lot of fun! I was very happy to see that the students were having a great time and were proud of their work on their projects. It was a bustling and engaging environment, and I was actually sought out by students a few times to come try their puzzles.
I think the main benefit to having the fair was that it created an engaging environment for the students. Everyone was excited to be out of school and presenting their hard work, and they were having fun teaching people about their puzzles and the artifacts. The biggest difference that would probably have to happen if I was to have a SNAP Math Fair at my school is that we wouldn't be able to go to a museum for it, and the attendance would be mostly in-school students and teachers. I think that because the students were from a generally more affluent community that a lot more parents were able to come. At Richmond Secondary we would be doing the fair in the gym.
I didn't notice any big issues with the fair. The only issue I noticed was that some of the students got to goof off a bit because they weren't supervised the entire time. I don't think it was that much of a problem because once the students saw someone interested in their project they gave them their full attention.
Tuesday, 29 November 2016
SNAP Math Fair
I think it would be very interesting and personally beneficial for me to run a SNAP Math Fair at my practicum high school. It would be beneficial for my resumé for obvious reasons, but as far as I have heard it would also be quite beneficial to the students that participate.
The SNAP Math Fair would be easily adaptable to a grade 8 classroom at my high school. I don't think that there are enough opportunities for students to practice and develop problem-solving skills in a typical classroom setting, so this would be a great way for them to grow.
I think that grades 8 or 9 would be suitable for the Fair because that is an age group that can handle a large portion of spoken-word math problems/riddles. Since it would be with older students than typical, we could develop the problems much faster than the typical SNAP Math Fair with elementary grades - probably about 4 classes of preparation. Then the actual fair could take place at lunch in the gym or the aptly-named Multi-Purpose Room at Richmond Secondary School.
The SNAP Math Fair would be easily adaptable to a grade 8 classroom at my high school. I don't think that there are enough opportunities for students to practice and develop problem-solving skills in a typical classroom setting, so this would be a great way for them to grow.
I think that grades 8 or 9 would be suitable for the Fair because that is an age group that can handle a large portion of spoken-word math problems/riddles. Since it would be with older students than typical, we could develop the problems much faster than the typical SNAP Math Fair with elementary grades - probably about 4 classes of preparation. Then the actual fair could take place at lunch in the gym or the aptly-named Multi-Purpose Room at Richmond Secondary School.
Monday, 28 November 2016
Math that matters
People tend to think of mathematics as a completely neutral subject, but after reading this article I'm realizing that mathematics is an all-purpose tool of sorts. Math can be used for good and bad. The Math that Matters text develops math education with a theme of social and environmental justice, but one could just as easily have a course that teaches mathematics in a way to help fool and steal from people, or lie with misleading statistics.
I think that this book is great. I believe that it promotes real mathematical literacy because students are being shown how to connect the mathematical concepts that they learn in class with real-world RELEVANT examples. This is much better than the way textbooks normally pose their problems with completely unrealistic scenarios just to make the numbers work.
A lot of these topics are covered in the Math 8 and 9 curricula, so I believe that many of these ideas will become present in my classroom. For older grades it might be more difficult to make connections, but one could easily relate logarithms to a social justice issue, and students could plot functions that are estimations of real-world trends.
I think that this book is great. I believe that it promotes real mathematical literacy because students are being shown how to connect the mathematical concepts that they learn in class with real-world RELEVANT examples. This is much better than the way textbooks normally pose their problems with completely unrealistic scenarios just to make the numbers work.
A lot of these topics are covered in the Math 8 and 9 curricula, so I believe that many of these ideas will become present in my classroom. For older grades it might be more difficult to make connections, but one could easily relate logarithms to a social justice issue, and students could plot functions that are estimations of real-world trends.
Tuesday, 22 November 2016
Baking Cakes
Eugenia Cheng claims that to bake a cake you need approximately the same weight of all of the basic ingredients (flour, sugar, milk, eggs, butter). Let's test this claim.
Some things that we will need to know are the densities of flour, sugar, milk, and butter because these are normally given as volumes in a recipe. We will also need to know the average weight of an egg without its shell.
From this site we get that the density of flour is about 0.53g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of milk is about 1.04g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of sugar is about 0.84g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of butter is about 0.96g/mL.
From the Chicken egg sizes Wikipedia page we get that a large egg (as is asked for in most recipes) weighs about 60g, but that 13% of an egg's weight is its shell. So let's say that the edible part of the egg is 60g * (1-0.13) = 52.2g.
Now let's look at our recipes:
1) Buttermilk pound cake.
Ingredients:
1 cup butter, 2 and 1/2 cups sugar, 4 large eggs, 3 cups flour, 1 cup buttermilk.
In grams..
250mL * 0.96g/mL butter, 2.5*250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 4 * 52.2g egg, 3*250mL*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*1.04g/mL milk.
That is... 240g butter, 525g sugar, 208.8g egg, 397.5g flour, and 260g milk. Not exactly equal.. this cake is high on flour and sugar.
2) Potluck Banana Cake.
Ingredients:
1/2cup butter, 1 cup sugar, 2 large eggs, 2 cups flour, and no milk - but 1cup sour cream.
According to this site sour cream has a density of 0.97g/mL.
In grams..
0.5*250mL*0.96g/mL butter, 250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 2*52.2g egg, 2*250mL*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*0.97g/mL sour cream.
That is... 240g butter, 210g sugar, 104.4g egg, 265g flour, and 242.5g sour cream. This cake is pretty close to having equal weight measures, but it is low on eggs.
3) Moist Chocolate Cake
Ingredients:
1 cup canola oil, 2 cups sugar, 2 large eggs, 2 cups flour, and 1 cup milk.
Google says canola oil has a density of 0.92g/mL.
In grams..
250mL*0.92g/mL canola oil, 2*250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 2*52.2g egg, 2*250ml*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*1.04g/mL milk.
That is... 230g canola oil, 420g sugar, 104.4g egg, 265g flour, and 260g milk.
This cake has average amounts of oil, milk, and flour, but its measurements for sugar and egg are way off.
After doing this analysis I believe that having equal weights of the main ingredients WOULD result in a decent cake in a pinch, as each has several ingredients' weights right around the same range and only changes one or two. Maybe this basic basic basic cake would taste bland.
Some things that we will need to know are the densities of flour, sugar, milk, and butter because these are normally given as volumes in a recipe. We will also need to know the average weight of an egg without its shell.
From this site we get that the density of flour is about 0.53g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of milk is about 1.04g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of sugar is about 0.84g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of butter is about 0.96g/mL.
From the Chicken egg sizes Wikipedia page we get that a large egg (as is asked for in most recipes) weighs about 60g, but that 13% of an egg's weight is its shell. So let's say that the edible part of the egg is 60g * (1-0.13) = 52.2g.
Now let's look at our recipes:
1) Buttermilk pound cake.
Ingredients:
1 cup butter, 2 and 1/2 cups sugar, 4 large eggs, 3 cups flour, 1 cup buttermilk.
In grams..
250mL * 0.96g/mL butter, 2.5*250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 4 * 52.2g egg, 3*250mL*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*1.04g/mL milk.
That is... 240g butter, 525g sugar, 208.8g egg, 397.5g flour, and 260g milk. Not exactly equal.. this cake is high on flour and sugar.
2) Potluck Banana Cake.
Ingredients:
1/2cup butter, 1 cup sugar, 2 large eggs, 2 cups flour, and no milk - but 1cup sour cream.
According to this site sour cream has a density of 0.97g/mL.
In grams..
0.5*250mL*0.96g/mL butter, 250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 2*52.2g egg, 2*250mL*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*0.97g/mL sour cream.
That is... 240g butter, 210g sugar, 104.4g egg, 265g flour, and 242.5g sour cream. This cake is pretty close to having equal weight measures, but it is low on eggs.
3) Moist Chocolate Cake
Ingredients:
1 cup canola oil, 2 cups sugar, 2 large eggs, 2 cups flour, and 1 cup milk.
Google says canola oil has a density of 0.92g/mL.
In grams..
250mL*0.92g/mL canola oil, 2*250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 2*52.2g egg, 2*250ml*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*1.04g/mL milk.
That is... 230g canola oil, 420g sugar, 104.4g egg, 265g flour, and 260g milk.
This cake has average amounts of oil, milk, and flour, but its measurements for sugar and egg are way off.
After doing this analysis I believe that having equal weights of the main ingredients WOULD result in a decent cake in a pinch, as each has several ingredients' weights right around the same range and only changes one or two. Maybe this basic basic basic cake would taste bland.
Sunday, 20 November 2016
Arbitrary and Necessary
When Hewitt calls something 'arbitrary' he means that for a person to learn this something they must be explicitly told. On the other hand, when Hewitt calls something 'necessary' he means that it is quite the opposite. Things that are necessary are called so because they must be that way, so typically these truths can be figured out (with some work) by oneself.
For any given lesson there may be both topics that are arbitrary and topics that are necessary. I think that a great way to figure out which are which is to try to teach yourself the lesson and carefully comb through it. By putting yourself in the shoes of a student and pretending to know only what they know can you figure out this idea? If yes, then the topic is necessary. If no, the topic is arbitrary and should be explained explicitly.
I really like this idea of necessary vs. arbitrary. Whenever I am teaching or tutoring students I always let them know when a convention arises so that they don't feel like they're "not getting it". I think that if we can create lessons that allow students to do the work and discover for themselves the necessary information then we will have done a beautiful thing. Planning lessons in this way is definitely more difficult, but the reward on the students' side is worth it. We always want the students to be 'doing the math' as much as possible.
For any given lesson there may be both topics that are arbitrary and topics that are necessary. I think that a great way to figure out which are which is to try to teach yourself the lesson and carefully comb through it. By putting yourself in the shoes of a student and pretending to know only what they know can you figure out this idea? If yes, then the topic is necessary. If no, the topic is arbitrary and should be explained explicitly.
I really like this idea of necessary vs. arbitrary. Whenever I am teaching or tutoring students I always let them know when a convention arises so that they don't feel like they're "not getting it". I think that if we can create lessons that allow students to do the work and discover for themselves the necessary information then we will have done a beautiful thing. Planning lessons in this way is definitely more difficult, but the reward on the students' side is worth it. We always want the students to be 'doing the math' as much as possible.
Tuesday, 15 November 2016
Things that surprised me during my two-week practicum
- I was surprised at how explicit the instructions that we as teachers give must be. Kids will take what you say at face value and completely run with it and they rarely ask for clarification. Seemingly, the students operate on the assumption that they are doing everything correctly.
- The "Light-side vs. Dark-side" view of the teachers and administrators in the school. We attended a staff meeting and the tension in the room was palpable.
- I was surprised at how little time it took me to feel comfortable in front of the class. Students had no trouble with me stepping in as their instructor. Maybe this is because they are so used to having new teachers. It just felt very odd to me that they'd trust me right off the bat.
- I was shocked at the fact that most IB students at the school started at 7AM some days, and many students started at 7AM everyday! I am teaching on 7AM class so I have to be there every second day at 6:45AM.
- I was surprised at how long it takes to create a good worksheet from scratch.
- I was surprised at the high stress levels of the students.
- The "Light-side vs. Dark-side" view of the teachers and administrators in the school. We attended a staff meeting and the tension in the room was palpable.
- I was surprised at how little time it took me to feel comfortable in front of the class. Students had no trouble with me stepping in as their instructor. Maybe this is because they are so used to having new teachers. It just felt very odd to me that they'd trust me right off the bat.
- I was shocked at the fact that most IB students at the school started at 7AM some days, and many students started at 7AM everyday! I am teaching on 7AM class so I have to be there every second day at 6:45AM.
- I was surprised at how long it takes to create a good worksheet from scratch.
- I was surprised at the high stress levels of the students.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)