When reading Richard Skemp's article on Relational vs. Instrumental Learning there were a few points that really struck a cord with me.
1) Skemp poses the question: How can we teach to a syllabus while still focusing on learning the material well? Shouldn't the class take the time that it needs, since understanding is much more important? Having a relational understanding of the material can allow for interdisciplinary learning and primes students for adapting mathematics into real-life situations, BUT learning concepts with a deep understanding takes a lot of time and effort. I think that curriculum should be more loosely based and focus on the grassroots - the formulas will fall into place later. Plus, students retain information much better if they've really learned it themselves.
2) When Skemp mentions the difficulty in assessing relational vs instrumental learning. This point stood out because I actually do not think it would be that hard to assess relational learning. Using material similar to those used in mathematics contests is a great way to test relational learning of students. I think these resources should be used by every mathematics teacher.
3) Skemp's comparison to building a mental map of the city stood out as an excellent metaphor for relational understanding. It reminded me of a time only last week when I was complimented on my knowledge of the streets of Vancouver in comparison to people that are new to the city. Being able to recall street names, restaurants, or bus routes at a whim is so comparable to having a heavy mathematical "tool-belt" and being able to apply it to varying problems.
I absolutely am on the same side of Skemp in this war of Relational Vs. Instrumental learning. Through my admittedly limited experience in teaching students in the BC Education System I have again and again witnessed the lack of relational understanding, and its impact on the quality of education in mathematics. Additionally, the majority of my peers at UBC still dislike mathematics and dismiss it as though it were wizardry because they were not taught to understand it properly when growing up. When I tell people that I have a degree in mathematics the response is generally "Oh, I was never good at maths". I believe that if mathematics was taught relationally rather than instrumentally that many more of these people could have excelled in fields that they currently think are out of reach, and would have more developed cognitive abilities in general. It is also important to note that so many of the things that are pushed onto math learners in school are now done easily by the smartphones that everyone has continuous access to, but which cannot grant real understanding of concepts.
Thank you, Fraser! Fascinating blog post -- I am with you on all these points. I love the idea of using math contest-type questions to assess relational learning (I've seen great examples of amazing student thinking and mathematical modelling with these). I agree that it makes much more sense to go in depth with fewer topics, and to foster a love and appreciation for mathematics, rather than to force people to rush through a superficial treatment of too many things. I love the city navigation metaphor too!
ReplyDelete