![]() |
| (My phone camera is broken so I had to borrow the photo!) |
My process when solving these puzzles was, I believe, fairly straight forward. The second rule of the game says that we must use multiplication to reach the products on the right and bottom of the grid, so I immediately thought that it would be useful to know the factors of these products. This is a tactic that may be slower to grasp if the solver does not understand mathematics as much as myself. I think it is more likely that someone with less understanding of factors would try to brute force the problem and work forwards instead of backwards, demonstrating fluency with multiplication rather than understanding the relationship with factoring.
What I first did was realize that 21 can only have 1, 3, and 7 in its column, and then quickly realize that 7 is not a factor of 40 or 24 so it must be in the bottom middle tile, and 3 is not a factor of 40, so it must be the top middle, and finally 1 is the middle middle. Once you have these 3 numbers placed the puzzle becomes extremely simple. Similarly for the (second) puzzle, you can use the same system as above but for the top row and its product 28.
I think that this problem would be at about a grade 8 level, because younger students might be intimidated as soon as they see that we have numbers multiplying together to get 378 and 288 and I believe that this is when factoring is introduced in more detail. A good topic to introduce with this game could be the Greatest Common Factor, and I think it could be used to directly identify problem solving techniques. After giving students time to solve the problem ask for a few students to share their method (In the same way you have asked us to do this :D ) to see that there are many ways to solve problems. This puzzle could also be a good question on an assessment to check the students understanding of factoring and GCFs, or you could create a similar problem involving primes.

Very nice, Fraser! Good solutions, and good to connect to GCF and related topics in Grade 8. I think this puzzle would work well at that age! PS: Is there more than one solution to #2?
ReplyDeleteHi, Susan. Sorry my picture was sort of difficult to interpret. The second problem had 2 solutions that I found, they are the second 'coordinate' in the (parentheses) for the squares, for the top right square it was 7 for both - I should have made that clearer!
ReplyDelete