In the far off land of Quasireal there were 3 legendary logicians - well regarded as the smartest 3 people that ever lived, capable of solving any puzzle. After many years of working together to solve all of Quasireal's problems the 3 logicians decided that they wanted to know who was the smartest, so an up-and-coming logician created a challenge for them.
The young logician sat the 3 legendary logicians down in a triangle so that each could see the other 2. He tells the logicians that he will be turning off the lights and placing either a white sticker or a black sticker on their foreheads. The 3 will not be allowed to peel off and look at their sticker, nor are they allowed to talk or communicate in any way except the following: If they can see at least one black sticker, they are to raise their left hand. The first logician to figure out which colour their own sticker is may declare "I am wearing a ___ sticker" and win the challenge.
After a few minutes one of the logicians declares "I am wearing a black sticker". All of the logicians were wearing black stickers.
How did the master logician figure it out?
The ultimate goal within this riddle was the test all 3 of the legendary logicians to determine who was the smartest. It would not be a good test unless it tested all 3 equally.
ReplyDeleteIf there were 2 black stickers and 1 white sticker that would be an unequal test because the 2 black sticker logicians would have the benefit of seeing the 1 white sticker, 1 black sticker and realizing that their own sticker would also be black because everyone would have their left hand up (they all could see at least 1 black sticker). The logician with the white sticker would be left in the dark. This is an unequal test.
The second unequal test would be if there were 2 white stickers and 1 black sticker. The two logicians with white stickers would raise their hands, because they saw a black sticker, but the black sticker logician would not see any black stickers and automatically know that he had the one black sticker. Again, too easy for one particular person and therefore an unfair test.
If there were 3 white stickers no one would have their hands up and it would be again obvious that all 3 had white stickers. Though this is an equal test it is too easy.
Thus with this in mind (unequal testing versus equal testing) the smartest logician realized that the only way possibility of testing all 3 of their wits equally was if the junior logician had placed black stickers on all of them!
There are four possible cases that can happen, either only 1 of the 3 logicians wears a black hat, 2 of the 3 logicians wear black hats, or all 3 wear white or black hats. Let us look at each case individually.
ReplyDeleteIn the first case, when only one of the three logicians wears a white hat. Obviously, for the two logicians with black hats, they will see one of each color hat. They will also observe that all three logicians including themselves raising their hands. By seeing one logician with white hat helps the 2 logicians with black hats to realize that if the 1st black hat sees the 2nd black hat raises his hand, the 1st black hat will know himself also has black hat. The same thinking works for the 2nd black hat logician. As for the logician with the white hat, seeing two black hats and both of them raise their hands doesn’t not help him to figure out his own color at all. Since this will not be fair for the logician with the white hat, we exclude the possibility of the first case to happen.
In the second case, when only one of the three logicians wears a black hat. Adopting the thinking routine we had for the first case, it wouldn’t be fair for the logician with the black hat to figure out his own color. Therefore, we will also exclude the possibility for the second case to happen.
The third case is when all three logicians have white hats. In this case, none of the logicians will raise their hands, and they will quickly figure out, they are all wearing white hats. Which is not challenging at all to test these legendary logicians. However, it is still possible for this case to occur.
The last case is when all three logicians have black hats. It would be hard for each of them to figure out their own colors. However, it is still possible to figure out the colors. By exclusion, since case 1 and 2 will not happen, only three white hats and three black hats will occur. Therefore, when logicians see black hat, they will be all black hats. And if logicians see white hat, they will know they all have white hats.
Excellent! It's an interesting logic puzzle, and Emma and Annie have done a good job explaining their reasoning.
Delete