![]() |
| The board. |
The question that comes up in this riddle is "Who is that man?" The reason this riddle is tricky is because we normally do not consider the narrator or riddle-poser to actually be involved in the riddle. Obviously, the riddle only makes sense here if the person asking the question is a man - otherwise it could be switched to an all female cast. We can notice that if a man says "my father's son" he could be talking about either himself or one of his brothers, but the riddle-poser also says that he has no brothers or sisters, so "my father's son" is equivalent to "me". Then "That man's father" is "me", so "That man" must be his son.
These riddles are fun to work with. I had actually seen both of them before they were posed in the class, but never in this way. Word problems like these may be much more difficult for English Language Learners, or even a person that is simply not a native English speaker. Exercises like these can demonstrate to teacher candidates the importance of phrasing questions properly.

Great solutions and commentary! Thanks Fraser.
ReplyDelete