Eugenia Cheng claims that to bake a cake you need approximately the same weight of all of the basic ingredients (flour, sugar, milk, eggs, butter). Let's test this claim.
Some things that we will need to know are the densities of flour, sugar, milk, and butter because these are normally given as volumes in a recipe. We will also need to know the average weight of an egg without its shell.
From this site we get that the density of flour is about 0.53g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of milk is about 1.04g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of sugar is about 0.84g/mL.
From this site we get that the density of butter is about 0.96g/mL.
From the Chicken egg sizes Wikipedia page we get that a large egg (as is asked for in most recipes) weighs about 60g, but that 13% of an egg's weight is its shell. So let's say that the edible part of the egg is 60g * (1-0.13) = 52.2g.
Now let's look at our recipes:
1) Buttermilk pound cake.
Ingredients:
1 cup butter, 2 and 1/2 cups sugar, 4 large eggs, 3 cups flour, 1 cup buttermilk.
In grams..
250mL * 0.96g/mL butter, 2.5*250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 4 * 52.2g egg, 3*250mL*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*1.04g/mL milk.
That is... 240g butter, 525g sugar, 208.8g egg, 397.5g flour, and 260g milk. Not exactly equal.. this cake is high on flour and sugar.
2) Potluck Banana Cake.
Ingredients:
1/2cup butter, 1 cup sugar, 2 large eggs, 2 cups flour, and no milk - but 1cup sour cream.
According to this site sour cream has a density of 0.97g/mL.
In grams..
0.5*250mL*0.96g/mL butter, 250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 2*52.2g egg, 2*250mL*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*0.97g/mL sour cream.
That is... 240g butter, 210g sugar, 104.4g egg, 265g flour, and 242.5g sour cream. This cake is pretty close to having equal weight measures, but it is low on eggs.
3) Moist Chocolate Cake
Ingredients:
1 cup canola oil, 2 cups sugar, 2 large eggs, 2 cups flour, and 1 cup milk.
Google says canola oil has a density of 0.92g/mL.
In grams..
250mL*0.92g/mL canola oil, 2*250mL*0.84g/mL sugar, 2*52.2g egg, 2*250ml*0.53g/mL flour, and 250mL*1.04g/mL milk.
That is... 230g canola oil, 420g sugar, 104.4g egg, 265g flour, and 260g milk.
This cake has average amounts of oil, milk, and flour, but its measurements for sugar and egg are way off.
After doing this analysis I believe that having equal weights of the main ingredients WOULD result in a decent cake in a pinch, as each has several ingredients' weights right around the same range and only changes one or two. Maybe this basic basic basic cake would taste bland.
Very nice, Fraser!
ReplyDelete