Wednesday, 28 September 2016

Cindy, Heejin, and Fraser's Nautilus Theodori


Rietzl's 3D-printed Nautilus Theodori
Our Handmade Paper Nautilus Theodori













Our Math/Art project was to create a replica of Rietzl's "Nautilus Theodori". The artwork is an extrapolation on the ancient mathematical artwork The Theodorus Spiral -- the original was a 2-dimensional creation, ours and Rietzl's are 3-dimensional.

This project was a challenge to build, but most of the difficulty came from the crafting part rather than the mathematical work. We only had to do some quick calculations to figure out the dimensions of the Nautilus and then the majority of the time was drawing, cutting, and taping it all together.

I think this would be a fun project for students in the earlier years of high school to work on because it can inspire interest in mathematics and how it relates to nature. There are many representations with the same pattern that occur in nature such as the real nautilus shell, sunflower seed placement, and rams' horns. Even if refraining from building the 3-dimensional model, I think it would be an excellent activity for a class to create the 2-dimensional Theodorus Spiral and solidify their understanding of the Pythagorean Theorem and Square Roots, all the while having fun and making art!

Sunday, 25 September 2016

Chess Board Puzzle

My apologies for the photo quality. This is the table that I
created to figure out how many squares of each size would
fit in a give square.

As soon as I looked at this puzzle I was hit with a feeling of excitement because I had an idea of how to do it right away. I recalled a technique that we had gone over last week in the EDCP 343 - Problem Solving class: solve an easier puzzle.

Instead of immediately looking for how many squares of all sizes could be fit into an 8x8 chessboard, I asked myself how many squares of all sizes could I place within a 1x1 chessboard. Obviously, the answer to this was just a single 1x1 square - so the total was 1. Going further I checked how many squares of each size could be fit in a 2x2 chessboard: 4 1x1s and 1 2x2; 5 total. For a 3x3: 9 1x1s, 4 2x2s, and 1 3x3; 14 total.

Now a pattern was starting to form and I was very confident that I had the solution.

I realized that I was creating the sum of the squares, so if I continued up to 8x8 it would be 1 + 4 + 9 + 16 + 25 + 36 + 49 + 64 = 204 squares total.

This problem could be extended into a third dimension to increase the difficulty and solidify the reasoning needed, or you could ask to find the total number of 1xX rectangles.

Monday, 19 September 2016

TPI Profile

I was honestly not very surprised by my results in the TPI graph. I view teaching as a fairly personal relationship with each student - maybe this is because most of my teaching experience so far has been one-on-one tutoring - so it makes sense that I would score higher on Development, Apprenticeship, and Nurturing. I personally did not understand the Social Reform category very much, but again this might be because of my lack of classroom instruction. To me Social Reform sounds extremely political, as though I were bringing an agenda to the classroom. This is definitely something that I do not support, so in that sense my low score is supported.

I am very interested to view my fellow TCs scores on the TPI, with special interest in the Social Reform score. I am curious to see what others have for it because I think that Social Reform is something that we does not often come to mind when talking about teaching. I also think it will be neat to repeat the TPI test throughout my career to see how my results change after entering the field professionally. I wonder how typical my graph's pattern is for a teacher with my background - I'd love to see how different cultures/countries score on the test all over the world.

Sunday, 18 September 2016

Multiplication Grid Puzzle

(My phone camera is broken so I had to borrow the photo!)

My process when solving these puzzles was, I believe, fairly straight forward. The second rule of the game says that we must use multiplication to reach the products on the right and bottom of the grid, so I immediately thought that it would be useful to know the factors of these products. This is a tactic that may be slower to grasp if the solver does not understand mathematics as much as myself. I think it is more likely that someone with less understanding of factors would try to brute force the problem and work forwards instead of backwards, demonstrating fluency with multiplication rather than understanding the relationship with factoring. 

What I first did was realize that 21 can only have 1, 3, and 7 in its column, and then quickly realize that 7 is not a factor of 40 or 24 so it must be in the bottom middle tile, and 3 is not a factor of 40, so it must be the top middle, and finally 1 is the middle middle. Once you have these 3 numbers placed the puzzle becomes extremely simple. Similarly for the (second) puzzle, you can use the same system as above but for the top row and its product 28.

I think that this problem would be at about a grade 8 level, because younger students might be intimidated as soon as they see that we have numbers multiplying together to get 378 and 288 and I believe that this is when factoring is introduced in more detail. A good topic to introduce with this game could be the Greatest Common Factor, and I think it could be used to directly identify problem solving techniques. After giving students time to solve the problem ask for a few students to share their method (In the same way you have asked us to do this :D ) to see that there are many ways to solve problems. This puzzle could also be a good question on an assessment to check the students understanding of factoring and GCFs, or you could create a similar problem involving primes.

Monday, 12 September 2016

Instrumental vs. Relational Ways of Knowing in Mathematics

When reading Richard Skemp's article on Relational vs. Instrumental Learning there were a few points that really struck a cord with me.

1) Skemp poses the question: How can we teach to a syllabus while still focusing on learning the material well? Shouldn't the class take the time that it needs, since understanding is much more important? Having a relational understanding of the material can allow for interdisciplinary learning and primes students for adapting mathematics into real-life situations, BUT learning concepts with a deep understanding takes a lot of time and effort. I think that curriculum should be more loosely based and focus on the grassroots - the formulas will fall into place later. Plus, students retain information much better if they've really learned it themselves.

2) When Skemp mentions the difficulty in assessing relational vs instrumental learning. This point stood out because I actually do not think it would be that hard to assess relational learning. Using material similar to those used in mathematics contests is a great way to test relational learning of students. I think these resources should be used by every mathematics teacher.

3) Skemp's comparison to building a mental map of the city stood out as an excellent metaphor for relational understanding. It reminded me of a time only last week when I was complimented on my knowledge of the streets of Vancouver in comparison to people that are new to the city. Being able to recall street names, restaurants, or bus routes at a whim is so comparable to having a heavy mathematical "tool-belt" and being able to apply it to varying problems.

I absolutely am on the same side of Skemp in this war of Relational Vs. Instrumental learning. Through my admittedly limited experience in teaching students in the BC Education System I have again and again witnessed the lack of relational understanding, and its impact on the quality of education in mathematics. Additionally, the majority of my peers at UBC still dislike mathematics and dismiss it as though it were wizardry because they were not taught to understand it properly when growing up. When I tell people that I have a degree in mathematics the response is generally "Oh, I was never good at maths". I believe that if mathematics was taught relationally rather than instrumentally that many more of these people could have excelled in fields that they currently think are out of reach, and would have more developed cognitive abilities in general. It is also important to note that so many of the things that are pushed onto math learners in school are now done easily by the smartphones that everyone has continuous access to, but which cannot grant real understanding of concepts.